Yesterday I received an e-mail from one of my girlfriends that had clearly been forwarded numerous times. The e-mail contained an image of an oil painting entitiled “Michelle & Sasha” by artist Elizabeth Peyton and it also contained a photograph of Mrs. Coretta Scott and her, then young daughter, Bernice. I was immediately taken back and angry when I saw the two images side by side.
My first thought was this, why would anyone place these two images together? I’m not certain if it was the artist was trying to connect these two African American families in some sybolic way. But, the artist failed miserably in her attempt. The image of Mrs. Obama and her daughter, Sasha, was photographed on a day in which this family was celebrating then, Sen. Obama’s (now President Elect) acceptance speach at the DNC in August 2008. This was a joyous and celebratory occassion for the Obama’s. In comparison, the image of Mrs. King and her daughter, Bernice, was photographed on the day that the King family and the nation as a whole mourned the loss of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. These images side by side are sickening to my soul and I am so shocked by them. Individually, the “Michelle & Sasha” painting is beautiful and it simply an image of a mother having a moment in time with her child.
I am an artist myself and understand the beauty, contrast, similiarity and all that goes into “meaning on canvas”, but this one is bit too dark for me.
In addition, since the Obama’s have two children I am concerned that one child has been “left out”! What happened? Was this the only image that Elizabeth Peyton could find to paint? Was the symbolism so important that for some reason she JUST HAD TO select THIS PARTICULAR IMAGE that is so quickly recognizable in comparison to that of “Coretta and Bernice”? Any mom would be a bit taken back to see only one child in the painting without the other.
I believe the artist needs to create “Michelle & Malia” to stand firmly with “Michelle & Sasha” as a set.
It is wonderful for an artist to bring out so many thoughts and emotions, but this image is very ill-placed today given it’s comparison and contrast to the most amazing Civil Rights leader of our time!
Just how much was given by Elizabeth Peyton to not only “Michelle & Sasha” but to the emotions of the country as a whole? Thanks Elizabeth for allowing us to “re-live” history through this image, it’s just what we needed.